Internet troll in court for saying disabled people should be exterminated is cleared because punishing him would breach his right to freedom of speech
Joshua Bonehill-Paine, 22, was charged over causing gross offence
Wrote an article recommending disabled be killed at birth
Also accused Tesco of selling Ebola-infected food on far-right website
Judge said his human right to free speech meant he could not be punished
By KIERAN CORCORAN FOR MAILONLINE
PUBLISHED: 19:08, 16 October 2015 | UPDATED: 22:08, 16 October 2015
'Proud anti-Semite': Joshua Bonehill-Paine had charges against him dismissed
+1
'Proud anti-Semite': Joshua Bonehill-Paine had charges against him dismissed
An internet troll who called for disabled people to be exterminated has been cleared of being grossly offensive because a judge decided it was his human right.
Joshua Bonehill-Paine, 22, was in charged over two articles posted on far-right websites, including one promoting eugenics – the practice of killing people whose DNA is seen as inferior.
A court heard that he said babies with conditions like Downs Syndrome should be killed at birth for the good of the nation.
Bonehill-Paine, who calls himself a 'proud anti-Semite' said that the UK should adopt the practices of Sparta in ancient Greece, where physically imperfect babies were abandoned on a hillside.
He accompanied the story, on a site describing itself as 'Britain's number one nationalist newspaper' with a picture of a Tesco worker with Downs Syndrome.
He was also charged over another article in which he claimed food sold by Tesco contained the deadly Ebola virus.
The articles – posted on two separate websites – resulted in charges of misusing a public computer network to propagate grossly offensive, indecent, obscene or menacing material.
But in a hearing at Stevenage Magistrates' Court this week, district judge Carolyn Mellanby dismissed both charges, saying that his right to free speech protects him from being punished over the stories.
Tesco said that they were alerted to Bonehill-Paine's article, and were contacted by almost 200 customers concerned that the story was true.
RELATED ARTICLES
Previous
1
Next
Joshua Bonehill-Paine, 22, was charged over causing gross offence
Wrote an article recommending disabled be killed at birth
Also accused Tesco of selling Ebola-infected food on far-right website
Judge said his human right to free speech meant he could not be punished
By KIERAN CORCORAN FOR MAILONLINE
PUBLISHED: 19:08, 16 October 2015 | UPDATED: 22:08, 16 October 2015
'Proud anti-Semite': Joshua Bonehill-Paine had charges against him dismissed
+1
'Proud anti-Semite': Joshua Bonehill-Paine had charges against him dismissed
An internet troll who called for disabled people to be exterminated has been cleared of being grossly offensive because a judge decided it was his human right.
Joshua Bonehill-Paine, 22, was in charged over two articles posted on far-right websites, including one promoting eugenics – the practice of killing people whose DNA is seen as inferior.
A court heard that he said babies with conditions like Downs Syndrome should be killed at birth for the good of the nation.
Bonehill-Paine, who calls himself a 'proud anti-Semite' said that the UK should adopt the practices of Sparta in ancient Greece, where physically imperfect babies were abandoned on a hillside.
He accompanied the story, on a site describing itself as 'Britain's number one nationalist newspaper' with a picture of a Tesco worker with Downs Syndrome.
He was also charged over another article in which he claimed food sold by Tesco contained the deadly Ebola virus.
The articles – posted on two separate websites – resulted in charges of misusing a public computer network to propagate grossly offensive, indecent, obscene or menacing material.
But in a hearing at Stevenage Magistrates' Court this week, district judge Carolyn Mellanby dismissed both charges, saying that his right to free speech protects him from being punished over the stories.
Tesco said that they were alerted to Bonehill-Paine's article, and were contacted by almost 200 customers concerned that the story was true.
RELATED ARTICLES
Previous
1
Next
Former teen neo-Nazi says ISIS is using the same methods to...
Actor dressed as Hitler on the streets of Germany tells how...
Neo-Nazi, 64, buys land in Nebraska 'in order to build white...
David Irving - British historian David Irving arrives at the High Court in London in this Tuesday, April 11, 2000 file photo, to hear the result of his libel case against American author Deborah Lipstadt and her publisher Penguin Books, over her allegations that he was a "Holocaust denier." Irving has been arrested on a warrant accusing him of denying the Holocaust, the Interior Ministry said Thursday, Nov. 17, 2005 in Austria. Irving was arrested in Styria province, said police Maj. Rudolf Golia, an Interior Ministry spokesman. He was transferred to a prison in Graz. (AP Photo/Adam Butler, FILE)
Holocaust-denying historian David Irving organises...
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Share
784 shares
Despite accepting that Bonehill-Paine was behind the stories, district judge Mellanby said he was protected by the Human Rights Act, which guarantees free speech.
She said: 'Freedom of speech has a very high threshold and I would have breached Article 10 of the Humans Rights Act if I had found you guilty.
'You have a right to express your opinions. You came close, but not close enough. I therefore dismiss the case.'
Bonehill-Paine, of Yeovil, Somerset, was returned to custody after the hearing ahead of a trial he faces at Southwark Crown Court in December.
He is accused of inciting racial hatred before a neo-Nazi rally in London in July.
David Irving - British historian David Irving arrives at the High Court in London in this Tuesday, April 11, 2000 file photo, to hear the result of his libel case against American author Deborah Lipstadt and her publisher Penguin Books, over her allegations that he was a "Holocaust denier." Irving has been arrested on a warrant accusing him of denying the Holocaust, the Interior Ministry said Thursday, Nov. 17, 2005 in Austria. Irving was arrested in Styria province, said police Maj. Rudolf Golia, an Interior Ministry spokesman. He was transferred to a prison in Graz. (AP Photo/Adam Butler, FILE)
Holocaust-denying historian David Irving organises...
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Share
784 shares
Despite accepting that Bonehill-Paine was behind the stories, district judge Mellanby said he was protected by the Human Rights Act, which guarantees free speech.
She said: 'Freedom of speech has a very high threshold and I would have breached Article 10 of the Humans Rights Act if I had found you guilty.
'You have a right to express your opinions. You came close, but not close enough. I therefore dismiss the case.'
Bonehill-Paine, of Yeovil, Somerset, was returned to custody after the hearing ahead of a trial he faces at Southwark Crown Court in December.
He is accused of inciting racial hatred before a neo-Nazi rally in London in July.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3276364/Internet-troll-court-saying-disabled-people-exterminated-cleared-punishing-breach-right-freedom-speech.html?ITO=1490&%3Bns_mchannel=rss&%3Bns_campaign=1490
Please give your opinion on what this report is about and what's happened on my email address sarajgorman@gmail.com
Please give your opinion on what this report is about and what's happened on my email address sarajgorman@gmail.com
Written by Tim Hodge published by Sara Jane Gorman
No comments:
Post a Comment